1733 5 minute how to read binary options graphs system
15408 best binary options hedging strategy review software download
9254 best binary option brokers for us traders
13562 binary option definition mt4 templates
8046 binary option strategies 360 montana
18883 binary option prediction market
18150 binary options brokerage phone sales representitive
18754 review options for help in dealing with a husband son daughter or other family member with addiction
4169 60 sec legitimate binary options brokers
5031 binary options algorithms for succeeding
8127 binary options affiliate program better investment and profit opportunity
2954 777 become a millionaire with binary options
227 apexinvesting platinum trader binary options review
16016 auto binary signals review warrior forum
10847 binary option trading ea review software download
15857 24 trade binary options 100 bonus
2401 amazon binary options buddy review
2848 1 hour make money with binary options trading strategy
7336 binary options bot forum
6093 advantages of binary equation trading
4357 are binary options taxable in the uk gold
10798 banker11 light binary options system mediafire
10585 24 hr binary option strategies 06426
13560 binary api
12000 60 sec binary options trading strategies minimum deposit
1421 24 binary option trading lowyat
3093 10 best binary options brokers for dummies
16000 accurate binary options signals review software download
14091 binary option system 96 glass
11207 binary option stock photos
9768 binary option buy sell indicator system 13
8925 alert binary options bully youtube video potential scam warning
3316 24option nadex 60 second binary options trading
8764 arbitrage in how to win binary options on sp
3772 60s making money in binary option system
11803 best option trading commissions
17518 amazon binary options robot activation key
16959 best option trading advisor in india
3856 99 binary options strategies 4 wealth
15577 5 minute binary options brokers mt4 signals
12438 assassin 8 the best 60 second binary options strategy
8577 binary option halal review analog to
1812 binary option university review options trading legal us
6620 are binary options regulated no touch strategy
11772 best option trading seminars
18317 60 seconds binary option strategy 2015 strategies s
891 best binary options platform fibonacci calculator and early closure
10729 best option trading courses
7657 binary options a genuine investment opportunity
1842 are binary options taxable in australia
8577 arbitrage in binary option trading group
19598 best options trading blogs
12903 best binary options traders forum
7514 best binary option signal
11343 0 100 binary options app scam
2490 1 minute how to predict binary options successfully system
665 99 how to trade profitably with binary option
5435 binary option 4 army
18184 automatic binary profits options hybrid
9886 1 minute binary options bullet coupon
6323 binary option live trading rooms
17703 assaxin 8 binary options companies in israel
1290 60 second binary option strategy indicator ea 2015
18969 arbitrage in how to trade using binary option
7853 binary option india legal
8107 assaxin 8 binary options free money
14375 1 minute binary options free white label strategy
10638 automated stock options trading
8047 5 minutes binary options strategy
6533 affiliate programs for binary options books
3086 5 alternative career pathways for binary options traders
19214 60 second binary options trading is it real
10253 24 binary options what is the catch review
1185 8 binary
14999 100 deposit bonus binary options xposed fx8
12389 arbitrage binary option strategy
14733 and get binary options broker free 100
9922 binary options a brief look at asx 200
9913 5 year investment options in india
10717 180 wins binary options signals service
12267 binary option trading in pakistan review options box
4532 arbitrage in reliable binary option broker
19876 best investment options in south africa
5435 amazon mt4 to binary options
955 best free charts for binary options
19497 best short term investment options 2014
5881 binary option trading usa review options brokers 100 minimum deposit
19168 10 minute binary options bitcoin strategy
11293 000 a night trading binary options
5884 1 hour no deposit bonus trade binary options 2015 strategy
5796 24 trade binary options trading 15 minutes
9257 best option trading schools
3847 60 second binary options 10 minute trend trading strategy strategies
11701 auto binary options trading review
261 best investment options in germany
8687 247 binary options wealth bot
6449 binary option tycoon who to make money fast
6805 5 minute binary options vs roulette trading strategy
17107 american binary options formula explained
13432 60 second can you make money from binary options trading mt4
15211 25 binary options no deposit bonus at optionsxo
11595 5 decimal binary options strategies for income
11833 1 dollar can i make a living trading binary options
15961 30 sec binary options strategy robot 2015
6124 10 best binary options brokers in excel
6582 american binary option blogspot robot 2015
16113 3 binary options system x paintball trading strategies for beginners
7165 60 sec eur usd binary options strategy
18373 binary option system dynamics
2431 10 minute binary options no deposit bonus october 2015 strategy
4629 anyoption jsp trade binary option strategies 360
10717 binary options and forex trading main diference
15408 bcsc warns against rboptions
13869 best safe investment options
10748 binary alternatives forex trading indicators
11383 best investment options during recession
14588 bank nifty option trading
13259 100 win free binary options demo account no deposit
15466 5 decimal gamma of a binary options
9321 arbitrage how to bet binary option
16955 binary option trading strategies youtube
9995 binary option trader forum
10556 5 minute binary options with a 97 success signal video
2875 15 minutes binary option strategy system 16
19500 alpari nighthawk system binary option
11208 arbitrage in binary options forex strategy
5490 accurate binary option signal 60 sec
17382 15 minutes live binary options trading room
5949 auto binary options review clickbank
10935 24 trade tick charts and binary options
12981 adx binary options strategy demo
5616 binary italia
16155 2 minute download binary options robot
7360 binary option system 32 virus
10000 24 making money with binary options trading starter kit scam
4834 are binary option a good investment trading signals
8072 1 hour binary options advisor
9438 binary option no minimum deposit
12262 binary option system board
497 binary option methods used to separate mixtures
7259 best investment options under 80c
17510 5 minute binary options trading babypips system
15133 1 minute binary option brokers signals
17924 best investment options sri lanka
18162 10 misconceptions all newbies have about binary options trading
13589 binary option magnet free download
16770 4xp binary options forex peace army demo
6521 24 bulls binary options free signals
1619 60 seconds binary options indicator trading software
14890 binary option strategies human resource manageme
Home Discussion Papers Finance & Economy Spotlight on the Ponzi scheme in Benin: Analysis and implications
Spotlight on the Ponzi scheme in Benin: Analysis and implications
Written by Catherine Pringle Thursday, 16 September 2010 08:00

In August 2010, what had started off as a tip between friends and the chance to transform meagre savings into mega profits, ended in tragedy for thousands of Benin’s impoverished citizens. The Ponzi scheme in this tiny West African country has directly affected more than 130,000 people in a nation of only 9 million.(2) It has also called the Presidency into dispute in a country that has long been an exemplar of stability in the region.(3) The repercussions of such a scheme may also go far beyond mere finances, affecting Benin’s socio-economic fabric and political stability.

The aim of this discussion paper is to analyse the Ponzi scheme recently uncovered in Benin. Specifically, it examines the socio-economic and political implications of the scheme on Benin.

An introduction to Ponzi schemes

Ponzi schemes are named after Charles Ponzi, who in the early 1900s conned the United States (US) public out of millions of dollars.(4) Recently, Ponzi schemes have been in the spotlight with the uncovering in the US of Bernard Madoff’s multi-billion dollar investment scam in 2008. Madoff’s Ponzi scheme caused a global uproar in the financial community and since the scheme became public, many other schemes have come to light. However, long before Bernard Madoff, men and women have been defrauding each other and the general public with the use of Ponzi schemes.(5)

In a Ponzi scheme, potential investors are wooed with the promise of lucrative returns on their investment with little or no risk. This is usually attributed to the investment manager’s savvy and skill. Ponzi schemes work on the principle of “rob-Peter-to-pay-Paul”, and money from new investors is used to pay off earlier investors until the whole scheme implodes.(6) Ponzi schemes can continue for as long as new investors line up with cash and old investors do not try to withdraw too much of their money at once.(7) Many Ponzi schemes share common characteristics, including: high investment returns with little or no risk; overly consistent returns; unregistered investments (i.e. not registered with state regulators); unlicensed sellers/firms; secretive and/or complex strategies; issues with paperwork and difficulty receiving payment.(8)

Ponzi schemes are different to Pyramid schemes in that with Pyramid schemes “[p]articipants attempt to make money solely by recruiting new participants into the programme. The hallmark of these schemes is the promise of sky high returns in a short period of time for doing nothing other than handing over your money and getting others to do the same”.(9) Pyramid schemes are therefore more transparent as they reveal to the investor the method of financial gain, which is to recruit new members. On the other hand, Ponzi schemes rely on tricking investors into believing that their money is being invested in high yield financial instruments, the profits of which originate from gains on investments and not the recruitment of new investors.(10) Ponzi schemes are thus a subset of Pyramid schemes, both of which collapse under their own weight and are ultimately unsustainable.

The case of Benin: Analysis and implications

The Ponzi scheme uncovered in Benin followed a similar course to that described above. The company in question was Investment Consultancy and Computering Services (ICC). It was registered as a non-profit computer services company and was operating illegally as a banking institution. ICC was forced to close on 01 July 2010 and since then, the Ponzi scheme has come to light.(11) ICC was promising Beninese returns on their investment of between 50% and 100%, and possibly even more and officials relied on word of mouth to attract potential clients, who were then met by consultants who promised lucrative returns.(12) Based on this seemingly attractive opportunity, approximately 130,000 Beninese invested their savings in ICC, resulting in financial losses to the tune of US$ 130 million in a country where most people subsist on US$ 2 a day. In a country of 9 million people, in which many families had pooled their investments in ICC, the losses attributable to the Ponzi scheme have affected up to a quarter of Benin’s entire population.(13) Moreover, Benin’s president Thomas Yayi Boni, a former development banker, has been implicated in the scam. Boni and other Government officials were seen on TV and news bulletins posing with the managers of ICC. These images were then reproduced on t-shirts and in advertisements by ICC, prompting most Beninese to interpret this as a sign of presidential endorsement for the company and therefore a sound investment.(14)

Since the revelation of ICC’s fraud, a number of actions have been taken. In Benin’s economic capital, Cotonou, crowds numbering more than 100,000 have taken to the streets demanding restitution.(15) President Boni has cleansed his administration of those associated with the company, including the minister of the interior, the chief prosecutor and the security minister. In addition, more than a dozen individuals connected to ICC have been put in jail, including the President’s cousin and two of the company’s senior managers. However, members of Benin’s National Assembly have cried foul, saying that these measures are not sufficient and that Boni was complicit in ICC’s fraudulent activities and should therefore be impeached.(16) The Government of Benin has denied any involvement in the scam and lawmakers have had the National Assembly’s request for Boni’s impeachment rejected on the basis that they did not follow the correct procedures. Lawmakers have approximately 50 signatures from the 83-seat Parliament, which falls short of the two-thirds majority needed to summon the president to trial for treason and perjury.(17)

A most serious implication of the Ponzi scheme in Benin is on the legitimacy of the state and political system. As a former minister in Boni’s Government stated, “[t]his business is a crisis of the regime, something that profoundly implicates the state”.(18) Since the move to representative governance began in 1989 with a populist uprising against the corrupt military dictatorship and subsequent elections in 1991, Benin has been an exemplar of stability in an otherwise unstable region. The fact that Boni’s Government has been implicated in the Ponzi scheme has sparked fear among analysts that citizens will again take to the streets in opposition to the Government as they did to depose the military dictatorship 20 years ago.(19) The widespread loss of confidence in the Government since the Ponzi scheme imploded, is a worrying prospect as such a large proportion of Benin’s population has been affected by the scam. The historic precedent of deposing unpopular presidents may again be deemed a legitimate option by Beninese in the absence of effective formal measures to ascertain the truth of Boni’s involvement in the scheme. Indeed, the head of Parliament’s rejection of the request by lawmakers to impeach Boni on the basis that the correct procedures were not followed, seems at best the following of correct legal procedure and at worst an attempt to protect the President’s wrongdoing from becoming public knowledge and to stop justice taking its due course. Moreover, with elections looming in 2011, domestic pressure on Boni can be expected to rise, thereby increasing the risk of political instability leading up to the elections.(20)     

 A second implication of the Ponzi scheme is on the socio-economic status of Beninese. Specifically, 130,000 people have had their savings depleted and in many cases, completely decimated. The loss of individuals’ savings is made more problematic due to the large number of dependants there are for each individual saver. Individuals with the capacity to save money (and invest in ICC) usually have direct and extended family dependants. Indeed it is noted that “[i]f behind every saver, there are only 10 people... then the whole country is shaken”.(21) Thus, the loss of savings due to the Ponzi scheme has deep socio-economic repercussions in Benin where investors in the scheme were mostly poor to start with and not high net worth individuals who could easily absorb the loss.

Concluding remarks

The Ponzi scheme in Benin was perpetrated by a company that took advantage of Benin’s population, which is largely illiterate and dependant on subsistence agriculture.(22) Investors therefore had little ability to ascertain the soundness of their investment or to understand the implications of the contracts that they signed with ICC. In the event of such a scheme, citizens should be able to rely on the state and its various institutions to bring the perpetrators to justice and where possible, to facilitate remuneration of investors by the company. The chances of justice being done and of restitution for investors in the scheme is looking less and less likely due to the Government’s possible involvement in the scheme.

While the Government has taken action to arrest perpetrators, the widespread belief of President Boni’s involvement and the seeming unwillingness of Parliament to address this issue has called Benin’s entire political system and its legitimacy into question. This is a serious threat to a young and fragile democracy and it calls for strong leadership to navigate the population’s loss of confidence in the Government, as well as the loss of livelihoods. Whether President Boni is capable of taking on this role, and more importantly, whether he can credibly take on this role in the eyes of the population, remains to be revealed in the coming months.  

NOTES:

(1) Contact Catherine Pringle through Consultancy Africa Intelligence's Eyes on Africa Unit ( This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it ). 
(2) ‘Ponzi scheme shakes tiny Benin’, News Limited, 02 September 2010, www.news.com.au.
(3) Adam Nossiter, ‘Scheme Rattles Benin, an Anchor of Stability’, The New York Times, 18 August 2010, www.nytimes.com.
(4) ‘Ponzi Schemes’, The New York Times, 05 September 2010, www.nytimes.com.
(5) Furman, D. J. & DeJoy, J. S. 2009. Before and After Bernie: Ponzi Regulation or Lack Thereof? International Review of Business Research Papers, 5(6), pp. 63.
(6) Ibid.
(7) ‘Ponzi Schemes’, The New York Times, 05 September 2010, www.nytimes.com.
(8) ‘Ponzi Schemes - Frequently Asked Questions’, United States Securities and Exchange Commission, www.sec.gov.
(9) ‘Pyramid Schemes’, United States Securities and Exchange Commission, www.sec.gov
(10) Furman, D. J. & DeJoy, J. S. 2009. Before and After Bernie: Ponzi Regulation or Lack Thereof? International Review of Business Research Papers, 5(6), pp. 64.
(11) ‘Ponzi scheme shakes tiny Benin’, News Limited, 02 September 2010, www.news.com.au.
(12) Cahal Milmo, ‘Thousands left penniless after collapse of Ponzi scheme’, The Independent, 03 September 2010, www.license.icopyright.net.
(13) Ibid.
(14) Ibid.
(15) David Lewis, ‘Head of Benin parliament rejects impeachment request’, Reuters, 20 August 2010, www.af.reuters.com.
(16) ‘Ponzi scheme shakes tiny Benin’, News Limited, 02 September 2010, www.news.com.au.
(17) David Lewis, ‘Head of Benin parliament rejects impeachment request’, Reuters, 20 August 2010, www.af.reuters.com.
(18)Adam Nossiter, ‘Scheme Rattles Benin, an Anchor of Stability’, The New York Times, 18 August 2010, www.nytimes.com.
(19) Ibid.
(20) Serge-David Zoueme & Emily Bowers, ‘Benin Political Risks Rise on Calls for President’s Impeachment, IHS Says’, Bloomberg News, 20 August 2010, www.bloomberg.com
(21) Ibid.
(22) ‘Benin’, CIA World Factbook, 05 September 2010, www.cia.gov.

 

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Plaxo

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner