essay writing on helping others
buying college papers unethical business
resume services des moines ia craigslist
advanced custom fields thesis
custom rolling papers uk
help emmett serve papers to arthur mcfly
essay a time i helped someone
executive curriculum vitae help wanted
cover letter services
professional essay writers australia weather
argumentative essay helpful words
essay on service learning project
where to buy a paper mache snowman head
where to buy a research paper urgently meaning
resume writers kingwood texas
how much to write my dissertation
professional resume writing services in ga
resume writing services brampton on
essay writers needed craigslist seattle
dissertation help in new york
writers at work the essays
where can i buy a paper fireplace
dissertation service learning
yorku essay help
professional resume services in portland oregon
resume writing service portland oregon
resume writing services vancouver wa
essay writing doctors orders
database assignment help
resume writing services in uk keyboard
how to write cover letter customer service
online chat rooms for homework help
weed helps me do homework
essay on multiple personality disorder
order of essay writing
cover letter sales and customer service
purchase custom essays uk
usda forest service research paper
manage quality customer service assignment
when did langston hughes write his essay my american
paper mario 64 helpers of gods precious infants
need help filling out divorce papers
essay about buying a new car
online paper writing service reviews
mba dissertation help
writing services for essays
cheap rolling papers uk
essay on service learning experience
vic uni assignment help
write my business paper
need help with your homework projects
resume services ottawa
history homework helper
suffolk county library homework help
good custom essay websites
cover letter for customer service and receptionists
professional resume writers rochester mn restaurants
dissertation proposal service
how to write my master thesis bound
writers block essay due tomorrow do tomorrow
buy paper shredder gears
buy home work
online essay help writing a cover
biographical essay questbridge help me
help on writing an essay paper
descriptive essay helper paragraph
dissertation help chennai express
cover letter customer service uk virgin
curriculum vitae help me lyrics
resume writing services reno nv news
cheap research paper writing under 50
resume writing services stamford ct map
homework help center columbus library dublin
help write a descriptive essay
homework help writing a story with spelling
buy asda paper shredder
letra de la cancion paperback writer en espaol
paperback writer video location
help kids with homework
how to help your child focus on homework
company custom essay help
best american essay writers
essay on customer driven marketing strategy
paperback writer bass tab guitar pro 4
urgent custom essays review
professional resume writing service milwaukee wi
resume writing services in rochester ny junk
personal statement help lawsuit
argumentative essay about cheating helps students learn
get to tha choppa assignment help
personal statement law school service
calculus homework helper
homework help on geography
essay about myself personality disorders
cover letter help nursing student
tnpl a4 paper online purchase
legal cover letter service rep
home help in essay writing lin tan wedding
write my philosophy education paper airplanes
resume writers eugene or
essay writer software online
dissertation help introduction to logic harry
personal statement help gt travel
resume writing services eagan mn
professional resume writing services in rochester ny
cover letter customer service resume
the order of learning essays on the contemporary university
essay on buying fashionable clothes is wasteful
resume writing services in st. louis mo
essay paper in civil services of pakistan
resume writing services ottawa canada shooting
assignment writers in mumbai india
executive resume writing service uk map
cover letter for management position retail sales
primary homework help britain html
essay on helping the less fortunate quotes
tonight i made the decision to ask alice to help me with my homework
how to write my law school personal statement
algebra 1 homework help and answers
what can i write my report on
virtual homework helper
primary homework help egyptians pictures
buy essays papers
help with personal statement for graduate school
academic essay writers reviews sarah
domestic paper shredder best buy
famous english essay writers scam
marketing assignment help
resume cover letter for insurance customer service
homework services inc
geometry homework help answers
calculus homework help chat
resume services york region ontario
buy a term paper college banners
where can i buy paper confetti
writer 39 s block essay definition
customs and traditions essay
sfpl live homework help
resume writing services salt lake city
buy stamp papers online
custom made paper plates
professional resume writing service sydney australia
cheap resume writing services toronto maple
noteshelf custom paper coffee
top curriculum vitae writing services australia
resume writing services in overland park ks
what can i write my psychology paper on a movie
resume writing services tempe az hotels
get writing paragraphs and essays 2nd edition by mark connelly
where can i buy paper wristbands in stores
resume writing services concord nh newspaper
essay writing help argumentative paragraph
pay someone to write my research paper
thesis writers services uk
resume writers in salem oregon
personal statement scholarship help you meet
custom essay writing service cheap
write my persuasive paper
dissertation editing help review
age essay henry ii middle new reign twelve writers almanac
professional resume writers bay area ca
personal essays famous writers of the 1920s
cheap essay writers ukraine
homework live help
purchase custom essays for sale
buy thesis paper online
best places to buy essays for cheap
argument essay vegetarian diet
answers for algebra 1 homework help
thesis writer responsibilities
cheap blotting papers
write my assignment for me australia news
park ridge library homework help
electrician helper resume cover letter
retail sales associate resume no experience
my favourite english writer essay
cheap resume writing services indianapolis
resume writing services frederick md hotels
homework help cincinnati library downtown
i need help with writing a essay
resume writers sydney
essay help proscan
the help kathryn stockett essays on leadership
homework help for students parents rights
custom writing personal statements
professional resume writers organizations in washington
common methods of ordering material in preparation for essay writing
homework help english poetry images
thesis writing service india lge
help with personal statement for teaching assistant
homework help reducing fractions powerpoint
paper buyers in dallas
buying paper for acrylic paints
paper lions ghost writers
college assignment help writing
samson when i write my masters thesis lyrics
research proposal essay writing help
custom college essay
targetdate series research paper 2011 industry survey
resume services upland ca
Home Discussion Papers Public Health - Discussion Papers Male circumcision: a possible silver bullet to reduce the spread of HIV?
Male circumcision: a possible silver bullet to reduce the spread of HIV?
Written by Elizabeth Zishiri (1) Sunday, 03 October 2010 08:02

Male circumcision is the surgical removal of all or part of the foreskin of the penis. It is a practise that has existed for more than a thousand years throughout the world, mainly for religious and cultural reasons.  In 2006, the World Health Organisation (WHO) estimated that 30% of men in the world had been circumcised. Male circumcision is commonly practised in Africa, but its prevalence is not as high in East and Southern Africa as it is in other African regions.(2) This CAI discussion paper appreciates the fact that male circumcision is a beneficial intervention in the fight against the HIV & AIDS pandemic plaguing particularly southern Africa, but aims to point out some shortcomings of programmes in implementing it.

Male circumcision and HIV & AIDS

HIV & AIDS remains the leading cause of death and illness, especially in Africa. Consequently,   attempts to curb the pandemic persist.  Male circumcision is increasingly being cited as one of the ‘the’ HIV & AIDS prevention strategies. As a result, following the 2007 recommendation by WHO/UNAIDS that male circumcision be included as an HIV prevention measure, Africa in particular is witnessing drives to promote male circumcision as a preventative measure against HIV infection. The recommendation pertains especially to Botswana, Kenya, Malawi, Mozambique, Lesotho, Namibia, Rwanda, South Africa, Swaziland, Tanzania, Uganda, Zambia and Zimbabwe.(3) In most of these countries, campaigns advocate for the circumcision of males of all ages, including children.

Research has indicated that male circumcision reduces the rate of male infection with HIV by approximately 60%. However, it is important to note that male circumcision reduces the spread of female to male infection; not of male to female transmission. It is possible and worth stating that that in Africa the risk of male to female infection is higher than that of female to male infection. This is due to the fact that sexual relations are largely shaped by the powers and desires of men and reflect the heightened sense of patriarchy in Africa. As a result, male circumcision is an intervention that protects men from contracting HIV from women but is not beneficial to women.

Points to ponder: male circumcision and its shortcomings

When considering the pros and cons of male circumcision, the most important point to ponder is that circumcision does not prevent HIV infection. Against the 60% that do not get infected are another 40% who do. Plus, the mentality of some circumcised men that they are immune to infection due to the fact that they have been circumcised has consequences for the spread of HIV, notably if and when they put themselves and others at risk. Additionally, circumcision is known to desensitise the penis. A man might therefore use force when having sexual intercourse, resulting in abrasions in the genitalia of his female partner, thereby increasing her chances of contracting HIV. Similarly, loss of sexual sensitivity due to circumcision can result in reduced use of condoms. Furthermore, men might also engage in sexual contact before their wounds are completely healed, increasing their chances of infection by an HIV-positive partner, or alternatively, in the case that they are already infected, resulting in them more easily infecting their partner.

Male circumcision, like any surgical procedure, has its complications. It can result in blood loss, infection, mutilation, penile amputation or, in severe cases, loss of life.(4) Some of these serious complications are caused by the lack of trained staff, poor or neglected follow-up procedures and the unavailability of appropriate and especially sterile equipment in already burdened health care systems in Africa.

Circumcision is also likely to encounter social and cultural opposition in places where it was not previously practised. Circumcision differentiates between cultural groups; it is an element of identity. Its prior association to culture and religion could in fact be a reason why some people might reject it. Additionally, fear of how circumcision might affect men’s sexual behaviour can be a contributing factor in opposing it. They might fear desensitisation of the penis resulting in lack of sexual pleasure and fulfilment.

Infant/child circumcision

Thus far the discussion here has related to adult male circumcision. However, as highlighted above, the drive for circumcision includes children. In some African countries, Zimbabwe for example, infant circumcision is being advocated based on the premise that when the male children become sexually active they will then have a lower chance of contracting HIV. This supposition is justifiable because it applies to the discussion above about the reduction of female to male transmission.

However, the shortcomings listed above also apply. Children like men also go through the risky medical procedure that can result in a number of complications or death. The cultural and social opposition to circumcision also applies to children in the event that their parents reject that their children be circumcised. In addition, circumcision of children is a human rights’ issue as children are not old enough to decide for themselves if they want to be circumcised or not so the decision lies with their parents. As a result, questions of the ethics of circumcision of its possible infringement on children’s rights arise here.(5) The viability of channelling resources on child circumcision is questioned considering that child circumcision will prevent HIV in the future when programmes exist that can address the present situation, taking into account how limited the resources are and how pertinent the issue is.  On another note, children that are put through the programme might already be infected and may die even before they become sexually active.(6)

Conclusion

This discussion paper supports male circumcision as an intervention to curb the spread of HIV because it does help reduce 60% of female to male infection but it also emphasises its shortcomings.   In some circles, male circumcision is being touted as ‘the silver bullet,’ almost as a cure for HIV. Campaigns should make it a point to clarify what male circumcision can do and the fact that it has its shortcomings. Campaigns should point out that male circumcision does not prevent HIV infection, that it only reduces the chance of male infection. Care should also be taken not to overshadow other preventative measures like condom use and abstinence. Furthermore, a lot more research should go into male circumcision as a preventative measure as well as delve into the consequences it has for females. Attention should be taken that the investments currently flowing into male circumcision are being well utilised.

It is understandable that male circumcision is generating attention because of the recent discovery and promotion of its benefits. However, caution should be taken on how it is promoted and implemented. The WHO could not have put it any better when it said: “Male circumcision provides only partial protection, and therefore should be only one element of a comprehensive HIV prevention package which includes the provision of HIV testing and counselling services; treatment for sexually transmitted infections; the promotion of safer sex practices; the provision of male and female condoms and promotion of their correct and consistent use.”(7) It is therefore clear for all to see that the peddling of male circumcision as 'a silver bullet' and not as an intervention that is part of a comprehensive plan is precarious.

NOTES

(1) Contact Elizabeth Zishiri through Consultancy Africa Intelligence’s HIV & AIDS Unit ( This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it ).
(2) 'Male circumcision information package', WHO, 2010, www.who.int.
(3) Ibid.
(4) 'Male circumcision and its links to HIV prevention', South African Medical Research Council (MRC), 2010, www.mrc.ac.za.
(5) 'Doctors opposing circumcision HIV statement', www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org.
(6) Ibid.
(7) 'Male circumcision and its links to HIV prevention', South African Medical Research Council (MRC), 2010, www.mrc.ac.za.

 

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Plaxo

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner