national stock exchange usa
nasdaq stock market graph of today
mobile vantage binary options review
binary option strategies of marketing robot
binary options weekly expiration strategy profit
the most honest binary options brokers jargon
binary options candlestick strategies
bet binary option queen
binary options weekly november 2429 2015
best binary option bonus mt4 indicator
online trading system of shares and securities
binary options magnet strategy broker job description
cfd 4 hour binary options
vantage the best way to trade binary options
how to trade options contracts
xm first binary options service
2 minute 60 seconds binary options strategy download
anyoption binary options trading software reviews
ny stock exchange hours on 12 31
where were the directors toronto stock exchange
what time do options open for trading
binary options brokers with free demo account xposed auto trade
99 binary options system event notification service
bank of china shanghai stock exchange
xp market binary options chart to use
binary options market share disclaimer
hong kong stock exchange results
binary option system grounding navigator
list of online stock brokers philippines
best home based businesses for women 2015
binary option trade records strategies qi
cftc approved binary option russia
binary options charting nadex strategy
binary options withdrawal
best stock market
ig markets binary options bot scam
how do online shopping websites make money
binary option trading guide pdf 3g
kim son garment and trade joint stock company
german stock exchange symbol
cimb stock trading competition
binary option secret strategy american
honest binary options brokers
1 hour binary option examples
how to read binary option signals one
5 minute keywords for binary options trading strategy
tactical trader advanced trading strategies
options trading lot size review binary option help
gold binary option system tools
binary option in us demo trading
penny stocks sites
us best binary option bonus companies
make a living markets world binary options review
forex vs dow jones binary options strategy
binary options vic video candlestick patterns
futures and commodities trading commission
forex trading training free download
trader 24 best indicators to use for binary options
legitimate binary option trading hours
binary option magnet results valuation model
best auto binary options review uk
free binary options indicator mt4 2015
stock market online exam
information on binary options with low minimum deposit
forex and binary options test
free live binary options charts jokes
binary option no deposit bonus october 2015 profits
top 6 forex systems surefire trading challenge
stock market apps ipad
is best binary options platforms 2015 regulated
is binary option haram live charts
binary option trade revie
binary option minimum deposit list autotrader
best us binary options brokers edge
binary options industry
binary options usa guidelines blog
options trading spreadsheet download
books for studying binary option
bb12 gold binary option system v2015
how the stock exchange works
binary options trading nadex blogspot
gold binary options systems ultimatum review
binary options evolution broker reviews
how to start a soap business at home
global stock exchange indexes
no deposit bonus binary option 77
stock market investment tax
international stock markets live
groupon binary options indicator free download
what is the difference between bombay stock exchange and nifty
stock market for beginners powerpoint
optionrally binary option legal
stock broker schooling
what is binary option channel 101
binary options methods 360 can you make money
taiwan stock exchange index futures
regarder la vido binary options optionrally bright us futures
worldventures compensation plan binary
sure shot option strategies
is binary options gain legal
london stock market gsk
binary option deposit methods 60 second indicator
daily binary profits sofware by option soft
us friendly the global binary options review
binary options system karaoke live trading
chicago stock exchange ticker
ted spread trading strategies
dow jones u s total stock market float adjusted index
futures trading systems review
option fair binary options explanation
binary options cheats trading platform
no deposit bonus in binary option 50
binary options winners easy
legit binary option platforms 100 bonus
how big is the binary option market youtube
motilal oswal securities online trading
what is forex trading australia
stock market club high school
how to work in stock exchange in pakistan
binary options trading over the weekend
how to start an at home business in texas
binary optionsstocktradingcoupon codes
24 hr binary options experts
disclosure requirements and stock exchange listing choice in an international context
binary option system one download
binary options elite trader green room
ea for binary options no minimum deposit
live news stock market india
wall street journal binary options trading platform
first binary option minimum deposit white label
top 10 trading binary options with nadex uk
german stock exchange close
binary option trading experience touch
vantage fx expands with new servers to keep up with binary options
my does trading binary options work free
good penny stocks tsx
binary options platforms usa income
regulated binary options sites 247
binary options brokers rating
binary options scams list demo
ig markets uk binary options using paypal
gamma of a advice on trading binary option
forex trading success strategies
o que e trading binary option amazon
stock broker lincoln uk
how are binary option taxed in the uk 100
stock market prediction using data mining
binary option brokers that use paypal in range
high mass x ray binary review
u s safest binary option brokers
value of binary option platform
how to win in binary options auto trading 100 strategy
b o s s binary options signal alerts
london stock exchange competitors
types of small business to start at home
binary option with 100 minimum deposit australia
forex binary options 400
binary options ultimatum system xposed
cm business currency trading
stock broker firms new york
binary option secrets earn money every 60 seconds system 76
binary options trading live signals robot free download 2015 90 return
binary options 100 win ra
cimb niaga securities online trading
what are futures in the stock market
strategies for algorithmic trading
what is a the binary options review trading system
forex binary options tutorial review jason fielder
no deposit binary options brokers 60 seconds trading strategy
binary options trading signal service kraken review
short term stock trading rules
short term stock trading books
one two trade binary option news
goptions review 30 seconds email conformation binary options trading
malta stock exchange company announcements
mexico stock exchange listing requirements
city index binary options in the us
chicago stock exchange volume
how to win in binary options 4 you
best settings for binary option robot org
anyoption smallest minimum deposit with binary options
best indicator for 60 second binary option 10 minutes
visit uk stock exchange
free books on stock market for beginners
binary option trading graphs no deposit bonus
binary options yahoo in usa
free binary options signal with 90 accuracy
is binary options pro signals a scam nadex review
Home Discussion Papers Conflict & Terrorism Regionalism, ethnicity, and tribes in the trial of Libya's democratic transition
Regionalism, ethnicity, and tribes in the trial of Libya's democratic transition
Written by Chloe Gleitz (1) Monday, 17 October 2011 08:00

In February 2011, protests challenging Muammar Al-Gaddafi's 42-year rule and the bloody crackdown have plunged Libya into a spiral of violence. Clashes between opposition and loyalist forces have led thousands to flee the country. While the rebels, headed by the National Transitional Council, rapidly took control of eastern Libya, the regime first managed to consolidate its power in much of the west and jeopardise the rebels' positions in the east.(2) But fears of massacres have resulted in the adoption of the UN Security Council Resolution 1973: the enforcement of a no-fly zone over Libya following 17 March 2011 and the engagement of a NATO-led coalition alongside the Libyan opposition force. After months of fighting, the fall in August 2011 of the capital city of Tripoli into rebel hands has marked the crumbling of the Libyan regime and Libya's possible shot at democracy.(3)

However, four scenarios may negatively affect prospects for democratisation in Libya: civil/tribal war, military rule, getting stuck in transition, and partition.(4) Unlike in Egypt or Tunisia, political structures and state institutions will have to emerge from the ground up. Of the greatest problems that the Libyan rebels will face, as they turn from rebels into leaders, are the country's historical ethnic, tribal, and regional splits.(5) Dissensions, both inside and outside the National Transitional Council, could although not necessarily, lead to a polarisation of the Libyan people along these lines and, thereby, endanger any democratising processes.(6)

Libya's historical divisions

The Libyan people are in culture, language (Arabic), and religion (Sunni Islam) largely homogeneous. Yet, they remain crossed by several historical divisions, on which any attempt at democracy is likely to hinge upon. In a context marked by ongoing violence and the general absence of formal structures through which to govern, some raise the spectre of fuelled regional, ethnic, and tribal enmities.

Widely exploited by a regime under attack and yet discarded by many of the youth who started off the Libyan uprising, the issue of tribes and tribalism remains a serious source of concern in post-Gaddafi Libya.(7) While existing, ethnic differences are downplayed by an overwhelming Arab and Berber majority (97%), which leaves little place for any major ethnical strife.(8) More worrying is the tribal fabric of a country home to more than 140 tribes and clans. Despite Gaddafi's attempts to destroy the power and influence of tribes and tribal leaders since his seizure of power in 1969, to the early 1990s, when he formed the People's Social Leadership Committees,(9) tribes have remained the main source of allegiance along with family. The reason for that is the absence of independent civil organisations such as political parties, independent trade unions, and business circles, considered by Gaddafi as potential centres of revolt or protest.(10) Crucial in determining Muammar Gaddafi's fate, tribes are presently likely to affect Libya's political transition and democratic chances.

Another major fault line may be the one existing between the ancient regions of Tripolitania and Cyrenaica. The Cyrenaican region has a long and rich history that dates back to the seventh century B.C. Successively ruled by the Greeks, Romans, Arabs, Ottomans, Italians and British, Cyrenaica has long been at odds with the rival province of Tripolitania, founded by the Phoenicians, and later conquered by Greeks from Cyrenaica.(11) This rivalry explains how, from the time of Libya's independence through to the reign of King Idris I,(12) the country came to have two capitals: Tripoli, the official capital in the west, and Benghazi, King Idris' power base and de facto capital in the east. It is no mistake that the Libyan revolution began in Cyrenaica, long bridled under Gaddafi's control and the scene of small and unsuccessful uprisings.(13) However, rebels have by no means been confined to Cyrenaica. Rebels in the coastal town of Misrata have waged a long and bloody fight against Government forces. And, while eastern-based rebels are bogged down in Ajdabiya and Marsa el Brega, Berber guerrillas, based in the Nafusa Mountains applied, constant pressure on the loyalist forces in the west and eventually joined Arab rebels from coastal towns such as Zawiya to march on Tripoli.(14)

Dissensions outside and inside of the National Transitional Council

Umbrella group comprising mostly anti-Gadaffi forces, the National Transitional Council (NTC), must today surmount the dilemma of quelling the remaining areas of resistance without alienating large numbers of Libyans, meant to participate in any successful democratic transition.(15) With reports of reprisal attacks against suspected Gaddafi loyalists, if law and order are not soon restored, divisions could worsen and hinder any future reconciliation process.(16)

The NTC faces another difficult task that is balancing the demands and interests of the various factions that have combined their efforts to overthrow the Gaddafi regime. Tribal divisions have, ever since the beginning, belied assertions that the NTC is fit to govern. Newsweek journalist Babak Deghanpisheh thus reported on a meeting held in Benghazi, in March 2011. Gathered to express their support to the interim NTC, rebel tribal leaders then showed all but little unity: while some praised their own tribesmen's role in the uprising, others drowned them out with cries of “Libya! Libya!,” hurling that no tribe would take credit above any other.(17)

In a highly fragmented Libya, the danger of a fractured alliance looms. Many are the examples of alliances fractured once the main unifying goal is achieved. Following the overthrow of their respective regime in 1991 et 1992, Somalia and Afghanistan, two highly fragmented societies, followed a similar path to chaos. In both cases, rebel warlords became locked in a struggle of power that plunged their countries into a period of destructive anarchy. The 1979 revolution in Nicaragua provides another example of a fractured alliance; this time in a country bereft of strong clan or tribal structures: turning on its former partners to seize power, the Sandinista National Liberation Front pushed revolutionary heroes such as Eden Pastora to join the contras and engage in a 10-year long civil war.(18)

To avoid the gloomy prospects of post-authoritarian civil war, civilian and military leaders of the Libyan opposition will have to work towards a fair recognition of each’ rights in a free Libya, all the while containing tribal and regional polarisation, as well as rivalries between the NTC and the Military Council. The legitimacy of the NTC-leading rebel officers(19) raises another issue that is one of military rule. However likely it may be, the spectre of a military-ruled Libya goes against the anti-military-autocratic move that currently sweeps North Africa. Given Libya's lack of democratic experience, getting stuck in transition is another possible outcome that may be hampered by the rapid submission to vote for a democratic constitution, backed by independent control mechanisms and accountability measures, to avoid the pitfalls of electoral fraud, skewed representation of human rights violations, and restrictions on civil liberties. As of partition, a potential divide between the three old provinces of Cyrenaica, Tripolitania, and Fezzan could be complicated by the absence of fully established administrative borders clearly demarcating them.(20)

Concluding remarks

Divided and flooded with arms, Libya's first and main concern will be the restoration of law and order. While tribes and clans will influence Libya's transition, the current situation leaves us with only an inkling of future developments. However, these should be affected by the political outcomes in Egypt and Tunisia. Standing in the way of civil war and military dictatorship, either one or both of these neighbouring countries could provide Libya with successful transition models.


(1) Contact Chloe Gleitz through Consultancy Africa Intelligence's Conflict and Terrorism Unit ( This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it ).
(2) ‘A Guide to Protests In Middle East, North Africa’, National Public Radio, 13 April 2011,
(3) Ibid.
(4) Ashour, O., ‘Libya after Qaddafi’, European Daily, 16 July 2011,
(5) Stewart, S., ‘Libya after Gadhafi: transitioning from rebellion to rule’, Stratfor, 24 August 2011,
(6) Alaaldin, R., ‘Libya's revolutionaries have divisions to bridge’, The Guardian, 31 August 2011,
(7) Dehghanpisheh, B., ‘Tribes mean trouble’, Newsweek Magazine, 13 March 2011,
(8) ‘Libye’, University of Laval, 19 July 2011,; ‘Libye-ethnies’,
(9) The People's Social Leadership Committees is a nationwide organization, beginning at the local level and made up largely of traditional tribal leaders.
(10) ‘How do Libya's tribes impact the country?’, National Public Radio, 25 February 2011,
(11) Stewart, S., ‘Libya after Gadhafi: transitioning from rebellion to rule’, Stratfor, 24 August 2011,
(12) King Idris I, also known as Muhammad Idris Bin Muhammad Al-Mahdi As-Senussi, was the first and only king of Libya, reigning from 1951 to 1969, and the Chief of the Senussi Muslim order.
(13) The Jihadist Libyan Islamic Fighting Group's strongholds are to be found in eastern Cyrenaican cities such as Benghazi and Darnah, where anti-Qaddafi sentiment and economic hardship have favored mobilisation movements against the regime.
(14) Stewart, S., ‘Libya after Gadhafi: transitioning from rebellion to rule’, Stratfor, 24 August 2011,
(15) ‘Building party politics in Libya’, Frontier Middle East and Africa Research and Advisory, 23 September 2011,
(16) ‘Libyan rebels must stop reprisal attacks’, Amnesty International, 13 September 2011,
(17) Dehghanpisheh, B., ‘Tribes mean trouble’, Newsweek Magazine, 13 March 2011,
(18) Stewart, S., ‘Libya after Gadhafi: transitioning from rebellion to rule’, Stratfor, 24 August 2011,
(19) General Soliman Mahmoud, Colonel Khalifa Haftar, Major Mohamed Najm, and others hold a mix of historical and current legitimacy from their involvement in the 1969 coup against the monarchy and in the 17th February revolution.
(20) Ashour, O., ‘Libya after Qaddafi’, European Daily, 16 July 2011,


Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Plaxo