cash advance wichita falls tx
quicken loans no closing costs
money bank kalkulator
personal loan india sbi
government loans for dental school
franklin capital auto loans
student loans company freephone
payday loan brighton mi
are there any reliable payday loan sites
payday loans poor credit uk
st louis jewelry and loan
va loan limits in nc
north star finance loans
loaning kindle books to family uk
loans on the same day
hr letter for loan purpose
online payday loans for low income
payday loans banned in ny
payday same day
credit cards with no foreign transaction fees
icici bank home loan pre approval
no employment verification mortgage loans
how to take loan in uninor
cool cash web loans
payday loans online washington state
payday support center.com
hdfc bank personal loan offer
small business loan rates 2014
2014 holiday and payday calendar
how does credit card cash advance interest work
easy personal loans unemployed
express check advance sumter sc
westpac credit cards apply online
cash converters ad song 2014
usa payday loans in aurora il
i need a no credit check loan with a direct lender
age to get a loan
lloyds tsb loans criteria
quicken loans 3rd party costs
apply for a credit card to help build my credit
hsbc personal loan calculator singapore
personal loan bank of baroda
who can borrow at the prime rate
credit union loans in sheffield
loans of 500
best interest rate payday loans
personal loans online standard bank
finance online pty ltd
international home loan japan
all payday loan lenders in the uk
african bank personal loan online
gift money for fha loan
100 home equity lines of credit
bay equity home loans san francisco
mortgage lenders in ohio
cash loan for poor credit
advice on loans
how to apply for loan modification program
advance america boise
fast cash working from home
how to get bike finance with bad credit
best mortgage lenders with bad credit
quick money on dragon city
loan depot keeps calling
minority teacher loan wisconsin
how to get money for anything fast stuart lichtman pdf
easy ways to make big money
today is payday question key 103
infinity savings and loans nigeria
do all student loans require a cosigner
pre qualify for loan online
best stocks to make money fast 2014
what is the best student loan repayment plan
loan company in lake charles la
bad credit auto loans st george utah
credit or debit for cash back
loan against property criteria
personal loan contact details
immediate cash assistance
would i qualify for a personal loan
24 plus loans faq
home loans in puerto rico
usda loans in illinois
bank of scotland loans contact number
very bad credit instant loans
check cashing places that do loans
i need a loan usa forum topix
vericrest financial complaints loan modification
knock down rebuild home loans
auto loans colorado
loan against work order in india
home loans that don require a downpayment
monthly loan interest calculator excel
economic hardship private student loans
payday loans in van nuys
mira loans phone number
paradise island game awards fast money
internet bank windhoek
cash for title loans richland ms
fha title 1 lenders florida
cash in 60 seconds guaranteed
washington mutual bank oregon
cash call debt
loan miami
budgeting loans from the dss
payday loans denver area
loan finance el paso tx
100 car loan
easy home loans south africa
computer based loan scheme management system
cashloan leasy
jpmorgan chase refund anticipation loans
sonic boom loans review
fha loan limits texas
is a personal loan an installment loan
commercial hard money loans miami
turning loans into equity
sbi education loan criteria
sim card deals bad credit
requirements for a loan from bank
instant credit limit catalogues
hard money lender orlando fl
how to get easy money in ultimate team
about payday loan companies
columbus ohio cash loans
guards loans liverpool
quick loans alberta
payday advance in corona california
devon loans chicago
bank of the west auto loan mailing address
online credit dispute with experian
speedy cash 37211
us loans rates
home inspection requirements for fha loans
maximum amount to borrow for student loans
ulster bank loans ireland
check n go employee reviews
groupon my cash voucher
instant tax service w2 loan
quicken loans employment opportunities
formula for interest on line of credit
how to get money fast in lotro
credit union loans doncaster
car loans for bad credit in austin tx
how to borrow more money for mortgage
payday loans eaton ohio
mortgage loans in charlotte nc
loan opportunities in ghana
onlinedirectloan lenders com
borrowing money against your vehicle
should i pay bills with credit card for rewards
quebec student loan online application
xpress title loans
payday loan in georgia
best online emergency loans
standard bank home loans client services
ubank home loan calculator
how can i borrow money with no credit
youth enterprise development fund loans
guaranteed credit for cars
get cash same day best online
how to get money in need for speed underground 2
knight online 100 cash
payday loans bensalem pa
plain green loans illegal in michigan
industrial loan in assam
0 interest bike loans chennai
loan zone arizona
usda rural loans in az
credit union loans in doncaster
eon key meter emergency credit
payday loan places in montgomery al
emergency personal loans for military
jumbo loan low credit score
vijaya bank online home loan statement
sell your stuff online for cash
student loan website myedaccount
more than one cash advance in florida
what happens if i dont have enough money in my bank account
loans i can apply for by phone
phone number for america first credit union
nova home loans in phoenix az
home loan brokers victoria
miami savings and loan miamitown ohio
checking account for those with bad credit
usda loan rates today
36 month loans direct lender
loan companies in knoxville tn
ace payday loans tyler tx
loans apr explained
car loan for u
load money to payoneer
time financing service eastern nc loans
lowest rates for personal loans
canada grants and loans database
earn easy cash online
loan for no credit check
calculate the monthly payment for a student loan
government loan instalment crossword clue
no credit check loans in oklahoma
Home Discussion Papers Conflict & Terrorism Africa: A testing ground for the International Criminal Court?
Africa: A testing ground for the International Criminal Court?
Written by Nayanka Perdigao (1) Thursday, 16 February 2012 08:04

Since its birth, the International Criminal Court (ICC) has had Africa as its most substantial client base. This can be interpreted as evidence of the poor governance systems that remain prevalent on the continent. On the other hand, it may present a bias in the Court’s focus on the region that offers the least resistance to interference in national criminal justice systems; after all, the United States of America (USA) is not a signatory to the Rome Statute that established the Court based on the argument of its robust domestic justice system. Reception to the work of the ICC has been varied as countries, including Côte d’Ivoire, Kenya, and Sierra Leone, have cooperated with the court while countries including Sudan and Zimbabwe have refused to work with it, with undertones of its use as a tool of the West. In addition, the Libyan National Transitional Council has been less than straightforward in its engagement of the court, as it has appeared to neglect its responsibility for trying members of the Gaddafi regime, including Saif al Islam Gadafi.

With the recent appointment of an African prosecutor, the Gambian Fatou Bensouda, this article focuses on the work of the ICC as it relates to Africa. The article analyses the ICC’s practice on the African continent, outlining its paradoxes and its prospects for the future.

The birth of the International Criminal Court

In 1998, the international community adopted the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court to establish the first permanent international tribunal to try perpetrators of the most heinous crimes. The ICC was given jurisdiction over genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and the crime of aggression.(2)

The Rome Statute entered into force on 1 July 2002 and established a permanent, independent Court. As of 1 February 2012, 120 countries are States Parties to the Rome Statute. Of these, 33 are from Africa, 18 from Asia-Pacific, 18 from Eastern Europe, 26 from Latin America and the Caribbean, and 25 from Western Europe and North America.(3)

The court’s principal task is to investigate and prosecute cases of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes. What is often overlooked is that apart from its actual prosecutorial duties, the court must also carry out the investigations that lead to arrest warrants; domestically, these complex functions are usually carried out by the police force. The ICC only investigates or prosecutes individuals who are thought to have committed serious crimes against humanity.

The principle of complementarity in the Rome Statute stipulates that the ICC should back up national judiciaries rather than supersede them. The ICC can intervene only when national institutions are unwilling or unable to meet their obligations.(4) This would explain why the ICC could not intervene in Libya for Saif Al Islam Gadafi. This is also why the court often has thorny relationships with domestic Governments where state actors are suspected of committing atrocities such as with Sudan.(5) This is one of the many challenges of having such an international system of justice. If not backed up by domestic Governments, the court is actually powerless, leaving many suspects free to continue their crimes.

Some scholars and policy makers have suggested that for the court to become more effective, it should play more of an active role in encouraging Governments to fulfill their legal obligations(6) so as to prosecute cases domestically. 

Africa’s exclusivity with the International Criminal Court

To date, the ICC has only pursued 26 individual cases on the African Continent for potential crimes committed in the Central Africa Republic, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Kenya, Libya, Sudan (Darfur), and Uganda. There have not been any convictions yet. Sudan's President Omar al-Bashir was the first serving head of state to be indicted by the ICC for alleged war crimes in Darfur.(7)

More recently, the Prosecutor has also been examining the 2011 violence in Côte d’Ivoire, the 2009 military crackdown on opposition supporters in Guinea, and inter-communal violence in central Nigeria. The Côte d’Ivoire investigations led to Laurent Gbagbo becoming the first former head of state to stand trial at the court(8) to face four charges of crimes against humanity. His supporters are alleged to have committed murder and rape as he rejected Côte d’Ivoire’s election result and tried to cling to his decade-long rule.

These developments and others have raised numerous questions about the ICC and the role of international justice. On the African continent, many have accused the ICC of providing selective justice by only investigating atrocities committed there.(9) For instance, the African Union Commission Chairman, Jean Ping, said earlier this year (2012): “Frankly speaking, we are not against the ICC. What we are against is Ocampo's justice, what have we done to justify being an example to the world? Are there no worse countries, like Myanmar [Burma]?”(10)

Other criticisms stem from the fact that its actions risk prolonging conflict by jeopardising peace deals.  This was specially the case with Côte d’Ivoire’s Gbagbo.(11) Many Ivoirians felt that putting Laurent Gbagbo on trial at The Hague and not in the country itself could leave opened wounds in the country.(12)

Prospects for the future

Gambian lawyer Fatou Bensouda has been officially elected as the next chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) and will become the first African to hold the top post at a time when the ICC is almost exclusively focused on the continent. Bensouda, a former senior legal adviser at the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, which is trying key figures responsible for the 1994 genocide in the Central African state, got the job ahead of three other short-listed candidates.(13) Her appointment has been received positively by the African Union and on the African continent.

The question everyone is asking is how and if the election of an African prosecutor will have an impact on the ICC’s future as an international criminal court. Bensouda has been quoted as saying that her African background would give her an insight into the life and complexities on the continent, which would help be an asset for her job.(14)

However, those expecting Fatou Bensouda to suddenly stop investigating in Africa should not have high hopes. The future prosecutor has been unapologetic about the work of the ICC in Africa over the recent years. She was quoted as saying “We say that the ICC is targeting Africans, but all of the victims in our cases in Africa are African victims.”(15) Indeed, many victims of violence today are still found in the African continent; however, one must not forget other cases such as Afghanistan or North Korea amongst many others. If the court is workings towards justice and a more peaceful world, it must consider all cases across the globe.

Concluding remarks

The ICC has come a long way since its creation in 1998, yet it still has a long way to go. As an organ of peace and justice it must handle its current cases with care and efficiency, so as to truly become a meaningful and useful institution. Its current track record has been criticised for its heavily African ‘exclusivity’ and its possible impediments towards national reconciliation.

While the ICC as an entity is working towards ensuring peace and justice, it still faces many challenges by working at such international level of justice. The fact that powerful countries such as the United States or China have refused to recognise the ICC means that certain cases cannot be investigated unless the United Nations Security Council agrees.

The ICC should continue its work but should aim to assist in building national states and tribunal’s capacities to investigate and prosecute crimes at a domestic level. This would hopefully allow for lasting solutions to peace across the globe where atrocities against humanity are being committed.

NOTES:

(1) Contact Nayanka Perdigoa through Consultancy Africa Intelligence’s Conflict and Terrorism Unit ( This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it ).
(2) Kaul, H.P., 2005. Construction Site Fore More Justice: The International Court After Two Years. The American Journal of International Law, Vol. 99(2), pp. 370-384
(3) ICC website, http://www.icc-cpi.int.
(4) Waddell, N. and Clark, P., ‘Peace, Justice and the ICC in Africa’, Meeting Series Report, 8 March 2007, http://www.royalafricansociety.org.
(5) Ibid.
(6) Ibid.
(7) BBC Website, http://www.bbc.co.uk.
(8) Smith, D., ‘Laurent Gbagbo appears before international criminal court’ 5 December 2011 http://www.guardian.co.uk.
(9) Waddell, N. and Clark, P., ‘Peace, Justice and the ICC in Africa’, Meeting Series Report, 8 March 2007, http://www.royalafricansociety.org.
(10) Chothia, F, Africa's Fatou Bensouda is new ICC chief prosecutor, 6 December 2011, http://www.bbc.co.uk.
(11) BBC Website, 5 December 2011, http://www.bbc.co.uk.
(12) Maupas, S. and Rémy, J.P., ‘Laurent Gbagbo appears at The Hague to face trial’ 6 December 2011, http://www.guardian.co.uk.
(13) Chothia, F, Africa's Fatou Bensouda is new ICC chief prosecutor, 6 December 2011, http://www.bbc.co.uk
(14) Ibid.
(15) Ibid.

 

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Plaxo

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner