self employment loans in india
hdfc personal loan job
e loan approval
jewelry loans san jose
auto loans summerville sc
personal loans for tax debt
personal loans bad credit instant decision
amx loans wholesale
sbi yuva loan
home equity loans how do they work
consumer loan specialist job description
money mutual canada
ace cash advance columbia sc
best bank robbery movies on netflix instant
cheap payday loan fees with no credit check
companies that help repay student loans
financing small construction projects
do student loans only cover tuition
home loans with 620 credit score
financial loan for
national student loans mississauga
instant cash loan
win instant money now
how to make 1500 dollars fast
payday advance grand blanc mi
how do pre approved loans work
how to transfer credit on glo line
payday bank review
leone industries
loan on line of credit
northern rock loan ppi
100 percent financing definition
payday loans no brokers lenders only
secured credit card 500 limit
instant cash back offers
freedom bank loans
loans with no interest fee
online bank kcb
payday 1 windows 8
cash advance from barclaycard
2500 cash advance loans
the moneylender and his wife 1514
how to remove a credit card from my apple account
beneficial loan interest
loan department chase bank
no fax no employment verification payday loans
how to get money fast boss 2
car finance loan bad credit
no credit check loans akron ohio
top loan modification companies
how many payday loans can you get in texas
new zealand home loans rotorua
the loan company essex limited
installment loans bad credit collectionusstates
payday loan western australia
pls check cashing locations in new york city
which is the cheapest loan in india
quicken loan home equity line of credit
canara bank loans on fd
dublin city council home choice loan
cash advance jacksonville north carolina
requirements for fha loans in indiana
what is the interest rate in a car loan
how to make money quick as a kid
fha loan denver co
instant online payday loans no credit check south africa
no cost loan modification
ufc 157 paydays
xpax credit advance
no interest dental loans
money lenders cork
no faxing payday advances
car title loans in southeast texas
i want to use my car as collateral for a loan
title loans in iola ks
same day flower delivery chicago
total lending loans
wwe money in the bank 2014 full show
topup your personal loan hdfc
24 advanced learning loan contact number
mutual of omaha sign in
get money fast simpsons tapped out
call of duty cash cow
cash cheques online
study loans for students in india
make quick money now
how to make quick money in vice city
check n go alta arden
what is net proceeds in finance
urban lending solutions salaries
loan repayment for nurses in ohio
check loan in utah
how do you get a lot of money fast on virtual families 2
payday loans in ilford
how to load money on cash passport
do all loan applications go to underwriters
is it hard to get a loan from lending club
mega loans farmington nm
abbeville loan mortgage
installment loans definition
crisis loans edinburgh phone number
does western union cash checks
check your student loans online
payday loan in my account today
pay in advance mobile broadband passes
quick cash advances
internet payday loans colorado
westjet advance check in
same night loans
weekly cash loans
nationwide building society business loans
mutual of omaha mutual directions 5
getting motorcycle financing with bad credit
1000 loan no guarantor
500 fastcash
online payday loan no direct deposit
student loans application 2014
money direct instant verification
how to get money fast with paypal
loan sanction amount
advance loan paycheck payday
loan in arrears
sbi loans system
no employment verification or credit checks for instant loan
txt loan contact email
lowest housing loan rates in sri lanka
bad credit loans for new york
does va loan cover foreclosures
student loans scotland contact number
montana first time home buyers loan
loan provider mae crossword
metlife home loans overnight payment address
ace cash 1800 number
low rate home equity loan
signature loans jefferson city mo
pnlne loan places
crisis loan jsa number 0800
unamortized loan costs
loans and monthly payments
best payday advance places
loan officer classes nyc
is it illegal to not pay back payday loans
24 advanced learning loans foundation degree
how to know when to cash in a savings bond
sst loan auto loan
get a loan with collateral
companies credit card processing
cash walk on the line
usda home loan raleigh nc
student loans that dont require fafsa
unsecured loan vs secured
best fast cash loan
payday loans seattle wa
what is an easy way to make money
wells fargo store loans
key bank loan payoff information
bank money deposit
cash loan austin
health xpress loans
fast ways get cash
pre approval for car loan with bad credit
borrow money for a car
cheapest personal loan in kolkata
one hour local payday loan
what to do if you cant pay back a payday loan
best payday masks
loan sharks in tampa florida
magnum cash
loan company belfast
loan application slot machine the end
loan companies vandalia il
missouri loan center monett mo
using 401k to payoff student loans
a bank loan vs overdraft
land purchase loan from lic
payday loans in burlington iowa
industrial loan policy
what is the best australian home loan
i be at the bank like get this cash off me lyrics
personal loan with collateral
are there any no closing cost loans
payday loans cheap fees
schedule rcc loans and lease financing receivables
how to pay back a student loan
payday loan in quincy
loans officer jobs in south africa
pre approved loan application
loans for bad credit toledo ohio
hard money loans with no collateral
the money shop benefit loans
citibank cash on call
can you get private student loans with bad credit
need a small loan asap
personal loans in peoria az
how to set up a money lending business uk
suntrust bank bad credit personal loans
westpac personal loan comparison rate
15 year loan rates calculator
how do i get a loan against my income tax return
do i need a job to apply for a student loan
Home Discussion Papers Africa Watch Somalia and the return of the international community
Somalia and the return of the international community
Written by Sim Tack (1) Monday, 02 April 2012 08:18

For the last two decades, since the end of the United Nations (UN) mission to Somalia in 1993, most members of the international community have largely ignored Somalia. In recent months, however, interest in cooperating with the Somali Government has returned and several countries have generated close relationships with the Transitional Federal Government (TFG) of Somalia.Much of this renewed interest is in reaction to the ‘political roadmap’ Somali politicians are establishing to guide Somalia into a new era of security and political stability. However, the argument could be made that the work towards political and social development that is being done in Somalia during this earlystage of reconstruction is ill-advised or ineffective.

The situation on the ground in Somalia has not changed very much from that of several years ago, yet the international community is suddenly showing great optimism about possibilities of peace and stability in Somalia. This paper aims to investigate what exactly caused the sudden change in policy that has resulted in the surge in international attention. In doing so, it pays particular attention to the security situation in southern Somalia and the political progress that has been made by the TFG.

Reasons behind the sudden U-turn

The initial event that sparked the return of international attention to the south of Somalia seems to have been the food crisis in 2011,(2)specifically, the initial declaration by Al Shabaabthat they would allow humanitarian agencies to deliver food aid to regions under their control.(3) This prompted an immediate reaction from UN agencies which quickly mounted a campaign to gather funds and deliver food to the affected regions in Somalia. The problem, however, was that the declaration by Al Shabaab was misinterpreted. Soon after the initial declaration, they published a list of humanitarian organisations that would not be allowed to operate within territories under their control and, as was to be expected, this list included all UN branches in Somalia.(4) As a result most of the food aid was delivered to Mogadishu and refugee camps in Kenya, while the epicentre of the food crisis was located in Somalia’s Al Shabaab controlled regions. Eventually food aid, from sources other than the UN, improved the food security in the region and the global response to the crisis was regarded as having been successful.

The food crisis brought political evolutions in southern Somalia to the attention of the world, which had previously been primarily preoccupied with the problem of piracy, originating mostly in the Puntland region of north-easternSomalia. Another major breakthrough during this period of renewed attention was the temporary withdrawal of Shabaab forces from Mogadishu.(5) The Government, up to that point, had only ruled over roughly half the capital city and the withdrawal allowed Government forces and African Union peacekeepers to grab more territory. However, while certain critical parts of the city, such as the economically and socially important Bakara Market, are still in the hands of the Government, Shabaab forces have once again infiltrated the city and continue to fight Government forces there.

Yet another event that contributed to the global attention to developments in southern Somalia was the Kenyan invasion of Somalia’s western border as a reaction to the kidnapping of aid workers and civiliansfrom Kenya by Somali pirates in October 2011.(6)Among the captives was a French woman that died shortly after being abducted.(7) The Kenyan military offensive, after the initial diplomatic ambiguity between Kenya and the Somali Government, spread beliefs that Al Shabaab was being defeated by these forces and peace would soon return to all of Somalia. In reality the offensive has ground to a halt and barely moved after the first few weeks. Not a single decisive battle has occurred between Kenyan forces and Al Shabaab.

A perceived successful response to the 2011 food crisis, temporary withdrawal of Al Shabaab forces from Mogadishu, and the Kenyan offensive against Al Shabaab have all focused global attention on Somalia and have created a certain sense of optimism regarding Somalia’s future. Policy is being formed as if Somalia has already removed Al Shabaab from the regions they control and the reconstruction of the country can begin. In reality though only several main Somali cities have been liberated from Al Shabaab and the country is far from reaching a point where democracy and development can become sustainable.The reasons forthe way in which several countries and organisations are playing along with the unrealistic view of a return to peace and stability in Somalia are unclear. It almost seems as if a belief in the arrival of better times is seen as a way to force an improvement in the situation in Somalia. It is true that Somalia has undergone some change, especially on some very significant local levels. However, the prevailing situation of Somalia being a failed state suffering from a raging civil war in which a radical terrorist group plays a prominent part, has, in fact, not been overturned.

The political roadmap

Perhaps the most notable progress made within Somalia has been that of the TFG and the establishment of what is called the ‘political roadmap.’(8)The TFG has been troubled by persistent in-fighting. Despite this, however, the Government that was formed after the ‘Kampala Accord,’(9) aimed at defusing tensions between President Sharif and the speaker of Parliament, seem to be working very pragmatically towards an end to the TFG’s  mandate in August 2012, when new governance structures are set to be put inplace.(10) The political roadmap has set numerous guidelinesfor steering Somalia towards more permanent political institutions and greater national security and stability.(11)The roadmap includes measure for drafting a constitution, achieving peace and stability, countering piracy and terrorism, as well as defining the procedures by which the next Parliament and Government will be selected.(12)

The handover of power through the organisation of popular elections, which had initially been a requirement in the TFG’s mandate, is looking very unrealistic right now due to the security situation in Somalia. UN personnel have already hinted at less democratic, but safer, procedures to select a new Parliament and Government. The real value of the political progress in Somalia will thus only be visible after the August 2012 deadline for a transfer of power. It is at that point that it will be clear whether the Somali political system has gained the necessary maturity to provide effective governance.

Turkish and British envoys

Despite persistent threats to stability and security and Somalia’s uncertain political future, several countries have reinitiated diplomatic contacts with Somalia. One of the pioneering countries in this field has been Turkey, which so far is the only one of these countries to have reopened an embassy in Mogadishu.(13) While the embassy is well situated in between African Union and Government military bases, it is a very bold move to establish an operational embassy in Mogadishu. The Turkish involvement in Somalia started off through humanitarian assistance projects in the city of Mogadishu but quickly grew to a more substantial political cooperation. Turkey has also started the process of awarding scholarships for Somali students to study in Turkey.(14)Turkish Airlines has also started offering direct flights between Turkey and Mogadishu.(15)

Perhaps one of the most visible states to be involved in the political cooperation with the TFG of Somalia is the United Kingdom (UK). Britain has appointed an ambassadorto Somalia but has decided to base him in the Kenyan capital of Nairobi instead of Mogadishu for obvious security concerns.(16) The British are much less visible on the ground in Mogadishu than the Turkish are, but the UK has pushed the Somali case up on the agenda for the rest of the world. The February 2012 London conference(17) on Somalia provided a groundbreaking opportunity for cooperation between Somalia and the rest of the world in establishing a stable democratic state in the nation.

Concluding remarks

The value of therenewed global attention being paid to the Somali case, as well as theinternational political support and development aid to Somalia, cannot be disputed.However,what is of concern regarding  the resurgence of international attention in Somalia is the lack of a substantial reason for a return to the country, especially after two decades of completely ignoring the conflict in Somalia. The actual worry is that Governments may be acting on unsubstantiated information, or with an agenda that is not completely transparent. The immediate future of Somalia is still riddled with challenges, the same challenges, in fact, that existed five years ago. The decades of ignorance and the current seemingly uninformed way in which certain nations have now suddenly decided to spend more resources on developing Somalia could prove to be a problem to the nation, rather than a solution. The situation may worsen, rather than improve, if the international community sticks to talk instead of action, or worse, abandons the Somali cause once again.

NOTES:

(1) Contact Sim Tack through Consultancy Africa Intelligence’s Africa Watch Unit ( This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it ).
(2) ‘Somalia food crisis reaching “unimaginable proportions”’, BBC, 6 June 2011, http://www.bbc.co.uk.
(3) ‘Somali rebels lift ban on food aid after drought’, Reuters, 7 July 2011, http://af.reuters.com.
(4) ‘Al Shabab reasserts foreign aid ban’, Al Jazeera, 22 July 2011, http://www.aljazeera.com.
(5)‘Al-Shabaab rebels withdraw from Somali capital’, Al Jazeera, 6 August 2011, http://www.aljazeera.com.
(6) Pflanz, M., ‘French woman held hostage in Somalia dies’, The Telegraph, 19 October 2011, http://www.telegraph.co.uk.
(7) Ibid.
(8) ‘Briefing: Somalia’s political roadmap’, IRIN, 22 February 2012, http://www.irinnews.org.
(9) ‘Agreement confirms extension of TFG, new PM and new Cabinet selections ’, Somalia Report, 6 September 2011, http://www.somaliareport.com.
(10) ‘Somali PM: transition must end in August 2012’, SONNA, 29 February 2012, http://sonnanews.net.
(11) Ibid.
(12) Ibid.
(13) ‘Turkey opens embassy in Somali capital’, World Bulletin’, 2 November 2011, http://www.worldbulletin.net.
(14) Abtidoon, A., ‘Turkey donates hundreds of scholarships’, SomaliaRe port, 28 September 2011, http://www.somaliareport.com.
(15) Omar, F. and Taxta, I., ‘Turkish Airlines starts regular flights to Somalia’, Reuters, 6 March 2012, http://www.reuters.com.
(16) Smith, D., ‘UK appoints first ambassador to Somalia in 21 years’, The Guardian, 2 February 2012, http://www.guardian.co.uk.
(17) Tran, M., ‘Somalia conference is a turning point, says Cameron’, The Guardian, 23 February 2012, http://www.guardian.co.uk.

 

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Plaxo

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner